Sunday Song # 8, "Lil' Cowboy Tune"
This melody has been stuck in my head for approximately ten years now. I think I first sang it in the shower when John Demartino and I were sharing a dorm room our second year at New College, which was late 2000 and early 2001. I never bothered recording even a demo of it because I always assumed chords and words to it were right around the corner, but they never came. I also think it sounds so much like some other song out there already, but I can't put my finger on what exactly. I played it for some of my old high school buddies and they started singing "P.O.W., M.I.A., M.I.A," but that is a song I have as far as I know never heard.
But so this week I spent a little while trying to put chords to it, which ended up being trickier than I predicted, and I'm still not entirely happy with the chord progression I ended up with. I don't think I've ever started with a melody before, although this is the way that some of my very favorite songwriters go about it -- Stuart Murdoch of Belle and Sebastian for example, and I think Dan Bejar from Destroyer as well.
And as for the effects I put on here, I'd initially had very tasteful snare drum, viola, and piano combination but it sounded so much like what you'd hear in the Ken Burns Civil War documentary.

